Are Kegels Really the Answer? When They Help & When They Hurt - Breakaway Physical Therapy
Shaina Clemons Health Tips

"Almost Daily Health Tips From Physical Therapist Shaina Clemons..."

Are Kegels Really the Answer? When They Help & When They Hurt

Kegel Pelvic Floor Exercise

Kegels have long been considered the go-to exercise for pelvic floor health, often recommended to help with issues like incontinence, pelvic organ prolapse, and postpartum recovery. But are they always the right answer?

Many people think that they know how to do a kegel, they understand the importance of strength in this area and there is no reason they could imagine getting support in this area. The truth is, while Kegels can be beneficial for many, they can also be ineffective or even harmful in certain situations.

Understanding when Kegels help and when they hurt is key to making the best choices for your pelvic health. Also understanding how to use the pelvic floor muscles properly is crucial in making a difference in any pelvic health symptoms you are struggling with.

What Are Kegels?

Kegels are exercises designed to strengthen the pelvic floor muscles. Named after Dr. Arnold Kegel, these exercises involve contracting and relaxing the muscles that support the bladder, uterus, and rectum. Ideally, performing Kegels regularly improves muscle tone, increases bladder control, and enhances sexual function.

To perform a Kegel exercise correctly:

  1. 1
    Identify the pelvic floor muscles that are on the bottom of the pelvis. Imagine you were emptying your bladder, and someone accidentally opened the door. You would have to quickly stop your flow of urine (don’t practice stopping your flow of urine on the toilet, this can be very harmful to the muscles over time; just imagine)
  2. 2
    Another way to think about contracting the pelvic floor muscles is to hold back gas as if it was not an ideal time to let it pass. The muscles around the rectum and the vagina (or penis and testicles) all work together when you do a kegel properly.
  3. 3
    Make sure that you are not squeezing your big gluteal muscles that you may be sitting on right now. Also make sure that you don’t hold your breath as that will cause excessive pressure down in your pelvic floor.
  4. 4
    Contract these muscles and hold for 3-5 seconds.
  5. 5
    Relax for the same amount of time. These muscles are small and need a break too.
  6. 6
    Repeat 10 times, 3 times a day.

When Kegels Help

  1. 1
    Urinary Incontinence: One of the most common reasons people do Kegels is to improve bladder control. Stress incontinence (leaking urine when coughing, sneezing, or laughing) and urge incontinence (a sudden, uncontrollable urge to urinate) can both benefit from stronger pelvic floor muscles when you have an underlying weakness in the area to start with.
  2. 2
    Pelvic Organ Prolapse (Mild to Moderate Cases) If the muscles supporting the pelvic organs weaken, organs like the bladder, uterus, or rectum can begin to sag, leading to discomfort, heaviness and pressure. Kegels may help by strengthening the muscles, providing better support, and potentially preventing worsening the prolapse. This is not always the answer, so if your symptoms worsen with kegels – STOP immediately and consult a pelvic floor physical therapist.
  3. 3
    Postpartum Recovery: Pregnancy and childbirth place significant strain on the pelvic floor, often leading to weakness. Kegels can assist in restoring muscle tone, improving bladder control, and enhancing healing after delivery.
  4. 4
    Sexual Function: Stronger pelvic floor muscles can improve blood flow to the pelvic region, enhancing sensation and sexual satisfaction. For some, Kegels can also help with orgasm intensity and control.

When Kegels Hurt

1. A Hypertonic (Tight) Pelvic Floor

Not all pelvic floor issues stem from weakness; some arise from excessive tightness. If the pelvic floor is overactive or too tight, Kegels can worsen symptoms like pain, urinary urgency, and constipation.

Signs of a hypertonic pelvic floor include:

  • Pain during intercourse
  • Difficulty emptying the bladder or bowels
  • Chronic pelvic pain or tightness
  • Urinary frequency or urgency
  • Back pain and tailbone pain with sitting

If you experience these symptoms, Kegels may be counterproductive, and relaxation techniques may be a better approach. Consult a pelvic floor physical therapist for optimal guidance on how to help your symptoms.

2. Pelvic Pain Conditions

Certain conditions, like vaginismus, dyspareunia (painful intercourse), or interstitial cystitis (painful bladder syndrome), can be aggravated by repetitive pelvic floor contractions. If your muscles are already tight and causing pain, adding more contractions can lead to increased discomfort and dysfunction. Stop the kegels. 

3. Chronic Constipation or Difficulty with Bowel Movements

A pelvic floor that is too tight can make it difficult to relax during bowel movements, leading to straining and constipation. In these cases, learning how to relax and lengthen the pelvic floor muscles is more beneficial than strengthening them. Understanding how to breathe and other tips for constipation will make a world of difference with your bowel habits AND your pelvic floor tension.

4. Incorrect Kegel Technique

Many people perform Kegels incorrectly by using the wrong muscles. Common mistakes include:

  • Engaging the glutes or inner thighs instead of the pelvic floor
  • Holding their breath instead of breathing naturally
  • Overdoing Kegels, leading to fatigue and dysfunction
  • Bridging their bottom off the ground thinking that is a kegel

Alternatives to Kegels

If Kegels aren’t right for you, there are other ways to improve pelvic health.

1. Diaphragmatic Breathing

Breathing deeply into the diaphragm helps relax the pelvic floor, making it a great alternative for those with tight muscles. Try:

  • Inhaling deeply, letting your belly, sides and back expand.
  • Exhaling slowly, allowing all your air to exit your body.
  • Repeating for a few minutes daily.
  • Try putting one hand on your stomach and the other from your side to your back to feel the 360-degree expansion when your diaphragm fills.
  • Read on in this blog for the link between your breath and the pelvic floor.

2. Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy

A trained pelvic floor therapist can assess your muscles and provide individualized exercises to improve function. Whether you need strengthening or relaxation techniques, therapy can be invaluable. They will uncover what is going on with your body, explain your symptoms and create a roadmap to help you get to where you want to be – optimal pelvic health. 

3. Stretching and Yoga

Certain yoga poses, such as child’s pose, deep squats, and happy baby pose, help stretch and release tension in the pelvic floor muscles. Practicing your breathing in these positions can also help to release the pelvic floor muscles. 

4. Functional Movement Training

Many everyday activities engage the pelvic floor naturally. Squats, lunges, balancing on one leg and hip bridges can help strengthen the muscles in coordination with the rest of the body. Any balance challenge will help to engage your pelvic floor in a good way and allow your muscles to engage properly to help stabilize your pelvis. 


How to Know if Kegels are Right for You

Since pelvic floor health is unique to each person, here are some steps to determine if Kegels are appropriate:

  • Assess Your Symptoms: Do you experience weakness (lack of pelvic floor control) or tightness (pain, urgency)?
  • Try a Pelvic Floor Check: If you can’t fully relax after contracting, your muscles may be too tight. Check in with your muscles throughout the day to see if they are staying in a tight state OR are relaxed throughout the day. Our stress levels can affect the state of our pelvic floor and it’s important to understand how work, family, life demands can be impacting your symptoms.
  • Consult a Specialist: A pelvic floor physical therapist can assess your individual needs and recommend the best approach. Educating you on pelvic floor anatomy, how these muscles work in an ideal state and why your muscles are not responding appropriately are so important for healing. Once you understand how things should work, it makes a lot more sense why things are not working for you and what is causing your symptoms. I promise, pelvic floor education is so impactful for recovery.

To Kegel or Not to Kegel

While Kegels can be an excellent tool for pelvic floor health, they aren’t a one-size-fits-all solution. There is NO blanket statement that can apply to all patients that have stress incontinence or pelvic pain or prolapse or so much more.

For some people, strengthening the pelvic floor is beneficial, BUT in others, learning to relax and release tension is more important. The key is understanding your own body and seeking guidance from a professional to help you. Whether you need to strengthen, stretch, OR find a balance with both, there is a path to better pelvic health that goes beyond Kegels alone.

If you are looking for support with your pelvic health and have been struggling for far too long, I promise we as pelvic floor physical therapists are here to help. We are here to listen, understand your story and provide you real life solutions so that you can live the best life possible. Ready to get started, give us a call at 410-721-6333 to set up a FREE consultation (we call it a Breakthrough visit) with one of our experts. You will have a chance to share your story and then you can make the decision if we are the right people to help you on your healing journey. The choice is yours!

Shaina Clemons

Shaina Clemons

Shaina is the founder and owner of Breakaway Physical Therapy.  She received her Doctorate of Physical Therapy from the University of Maryland Baltimore, along with a Bachelor's degree from Towson University.   Shaina is an Ironman triathlete, with a love of all sports. Exercise is her passion, which plays an important role in both her personal and professional life.  In her free time, Shaina enjoys spending time with her husband and three young children.  Shaina's love of snowboarding led her to her career choice many years ago. 
Share This
Google Rating
4.9
Based on 132 reviews
×